Calgary study finds earlier opportunities to intervene before domestic violence charges
A possible window for intervention
The study, titled Before the First Charge: Using Police Data to Identify Opportunities for Domestic Violence Interventions, identified four groups based on men’s previous police contact.
About 39 per cent had no previous police contact during the period examined.
Eight per cent had a previous criminal history but no recorded non-criminal domestic encounters.
Another 32 per cent had previous non-criminal domestic encounters but no criminal history, while 21 per cent had both a criminal history and previous non-criminal domestic encounters.
The report says those non-criminal domestic encounters are incidents where police attended but no criminal charges were laid or recommended.
It also cautions that such an encounter does not establish that a criminal offence occurred or identify who was responsible for violence.
Wells said those calls can nevertheless provide an opportunity to address behaviour.
“For many of the men who get charged, about a third had had a prior domestic violence encounter and many within the previous year,” she said.
“That tells us that police are showing up into these homes and there may not be enough to charge, but we need to think about how can we intervene and prevent that behavior.”
Wells said that could mean shifting some of the focus of police response toward the person causing the harm.
“Police will sit down with the woman and do a victim safety plan, which we’re arguing actually puts the burden of safety on her,” she said.
“We’re suggesting that police should be sitting down with the perpetrator and doing a prevention plan with him and thinking about him and the supports and services he needs to prevent the escalation of violence.”
Calls for more support for men
Wells said police intervention could be paired with community-based programs to help men address behaviour before it escalates.
“We need to change police practices so they’re actually working with the men and doing prevention plans and getting them the supports they need,” she said.
She pointed to organizations including Fear Is Not Love, the YWCA and the Men & Project as potential community supports.
“We need more robust programming and investment for programming for men,” Wells said.
“We need police officers to not just be working with the victims. They need to shift their practice to viewing the perpetrator as somebody who needs help and taking the time and doing prevention and accountability plans with them.”
Link to full story here.